Domestic Homicide Review (DHR) Safer Devon Partnership
Executive Summary – ‘Laura’ May 2022
Julia Greig, Chair and Overview Report Author
Date: 25
th March 2024
Contents
- The Review Process
- Contributors to the Review
- The Review Panel Members
- Author of the Overview Report
- Terms of Reference
- Summary Chronology
- Key Issues Arising from the Review
- Conclusion and Lessons to be Learned
- Recommendations
The Review Process
- This summary outlines the process undertaken by the Safer Devon Partnership domestic homicide review panel in reviewing the death of Laura who was a resident in their area.
- The following pseudonyms have been used in this review for the victim and perpetrators to protect their identities and those of their family members. Laura was a white British woman who was 41 years of age at the time of her death. Michael was Laura’s husband, he was a white British man and 44 years of age at the time of Laura’s death. Christopher was Michael’s brother, and therefore Laura’s brother-in-law, he was also a white British man and was 41 years of age when Laura died.
- The Coroner’s Inquest concluded in October 2023. The Coroner confirmed the cause of Laura’s death was ‘polydrug toxicity’. There were no criminal proceedings in this case in relation to Laura’s death.
- The review process began with an initial meeting of the Safer Devon Partnership on 19th July 2022 when the decision to hold a domestic homicide review was agreed. All agencies that potentially had contact with Laura, Michael and/or Christopher, prior to the point of death, were contacted and asked to confirm whether they had involvement with them. Seven of the thirteen agencies contacted confirmed contact with the victim and/or perpetrator and were asked to secure their files.
Contributors to the Review
The agencies that have contributed to this review are as follows:
- FearFree (formerly FearLess and Splitz Support Service) – IMR
- Devon Partnership NHS Trust – IMR
- Devon and Cornwall Police – IMR
- Together Drug and Alcohol Service – IMR
- Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust – IMR
- Medical Centre A, Devon – IMR
- Medical Centre B, Devon – Summary Report
IMR authors were independent with no direct involvement in the case, or line management responsibility for any of those involved.
The Review Panel Members
The DHR panel members were as follows:
| Name | Role | Agency |
| Julia Greig | Independent Chair and Author | Octavia Consulting |
| Becky McMurray | DHR Review Co-ordinator | Devon County Council |
| Lee Nattrass
Phil Hale | Detective Chief Inspector
Detective Inspector | Devon and Cornwall Police |
| Melody Trott, Dave Whelan | Anti-Social Behaviour and Community Safety Partnership Co-Ordinator, Emergency Planning and Business Continuity Officer | East and Mid Devon Community Safety Partnership |
| Gillian Scoble | Named Nurse Primary Care | NHS Devon Integrated Care Board |
| Paula McGinnis | Partnership, Service Development and Learning Officer | Devon County Council |
| Louise Arscott | Head of Devon and Torbay Probation | Devon and Torbay Probation |
| Alison Bolt | Senior Safeguarding Nurse | Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust |
| Anthony Vaughan | Clinical Specialist | Devon Partnership Trust |
| Marise Mackie | Devon Service Manager | FearFree Support Service |
| Kayleigh Bradford | Principal Social Worker | Adult Social Care, Devon County Council |
| Kelly Jones | Senior Manager | Together / HumanKind |
| Charlotte Pavitt | Consultant in Public Health | Public Health |
Independence and impartiality are fundamental principles of delivering a DHR and the impartiality of the independent chair and report author and panel members is essential in delivering a process and report that is legitimate and credible. None of the panel members, had direct involvement in the case, or had line management responsibility for any of those involved.
Author of the Overview Report
The Safer Devon Partnership appointed Julia Greig to chair the review and to author the Overview Report. She is a registered social worker and has extensive social work experience in the statutory sector working with adults. She has completed the Home Office approved course for Domestic Homicide Review Authors provided by AAFDA and is an accredited reviewer using the Serious Incident Learning Process. She maintains her CPD through Review Consulting and the AAFDA Network. She has completed, and is currently undertaking, Safeguarding Adult Reviews and Domestic Homicide Reviews in other local authority areas. Julia is independent of all agencies involved in this case and has never worked in Devon or for any of its agencies.
Terms of Reference
Statutory Guidance (Section 2.7) states the purpose of the DHR Review is to:
- Establish what lessons are to be learned from the domestic homicide [suicide] regarding the way in which local professionals and organisations work individually and together to safeguard victims;
- Identify clearly what those lessons are both within and between agencies, how and within what timescales they will be acted on, and what is expected to change as a result;
- Apply these lessons to service responses including changes to inform national and local policies and procedures as appropriate;
- Prevent domestic violence and homicide and improve service responses for all domestic violence and abuse victims and their children by developing a coordinated multi-agency approach to ensure that domestic abuse is identified and responded to effectively at the earliest opportunity;
- Contribute to a better understanding of the nature of domestic violence and abuse;
- Highlight good practice.
Specific terms of reference set for this review- Identify examples of good practice, both single and multi-agency.
- Analyse the quality of risk assessments undertaken. Were links between Mental Health (including risk of suicide) and Domestic Abuse (including historical domestic abuse) identified at any risk assessment?
- Whether risk was or was not identified, where can practitioners within your agency receive advice or support if they suspect domestic abuse? Was this taken up in this case? If this is available, would the advice extend to consultation or referral across agencies?
- Is there evidence of whether any identified risk had been assessed as reaching the threshold for inter-agency information sharing (including referral to MARAC)?
- What evidence is there of communication and information sharing between agencies? How could information sharing, and communication have been improved during the scoping period both within and between agencies?
Summary Chronology
- Laura was married to Michael; they had been together for fifteen years. She had separated from him twelve months prior to her death and had commenced a relationship with his brother, Christopher. It is understood that at the time of her death Laura had resumed a relationship with Michael.
- Although Laura was the only person named on the tenancy of the property she lived in, both Michael and Christopher lived with her at the property at various points during the time period in scope.
- Christopher had previously lived in Birmingham, moving back to Devon some time in 2019. In 2018 he was given a Community Order following an assault on his partner, a Restraining Order was also granted with the condition not to contact, directly or indirectly, his partner, except via solicitor or family court for the purposes of arranging child contact. The restraining order expired in September 2020.
- Michael had served in the armed forces and experienced Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. He suffered with angina and used alcohol which on occasions triggered chest pain and breathing difficulties requiring paramedic attention.
- The combined narrative chronology covered the period from the 22nd May 2021 to the date of Laura’s death in May 2022.
- On the 22nd May 2021 Laura told Michael that she wanted to end their marriage. There was an argument and Michael pushed and punched Laura in the face. Michael contacted the police saying that he needed to be arrested as he wanted to burn down Laura’s house.
- Michael was arrested and interviewed. Christopher, who was reported to be a lodger at Laura’s address, was also present at the time of the incident; he had witnessed the assault but declined to provide a statement. Laura also declined to make a statement and did not support any police action. Police decided to take no further action but recommended a referral to the Fire Service due to the threats made by Michael, although this was never actioned. The police completed a DASH, with the outcome of medium risk, and referred Laura to FearFree.
- Michael was assessed by Liaison and Diversion which identified that there were no acute mental health issues and Michael’s risk to others was assessed as low. A copy of the triage tool was sent to Michael’s GP, and he was referred to Together Drug and Alcohol Service.
- On the 25th May 2021 FearFree telephoned Laura. Laura said she did not require the service’s support and she was encouraged to call the service if she changed her mind or needed support in the future. The case was closed.
- On the 20th June 2021 Michael’s mother contacted police reporting that Michael was expressing suicidal thoughts. Michael was detained by police under section 136 of the Mental Health Act 1983. DPT undertook an assessment under the Act and during the assessment Michael discussed the recent domestic abuse incident. He said that both he and Laura had been drinking, she had grabbed his neck, but he did not recall hitting her. He said that he hoped he could rebuild the relationship. The assessment concluded that there was no evidence of suicidal plan, intention, or risk to others and therefore no further action was taken.
- On the 16th September 2021 Laura called the police reporting that she had been physically assaulted by Christopher. Laura told police that she should have spoken to police after the first incident. When officers asked what she meant by this she lifted her t-shirt and showed them bruising on her back and around her chest/breast area. She said that the injuries were caused by Christopher three days prior. Laura also reported that Christopher had thrown her laptop causing damage beyond repair. Laura allowed police to photograph her injuries and provided police with a statement.
- Christopher was arrested and interviewed. The decision was made to take no further action in relation to the assault because Christopher stated during interview that he had acted in self-defence. Christopher was issued with a formal caution for criminal damage.
- A DASH was completed with Laura. The DASH recorded multiple bruises and marks to Laura’s neck and Laura said that she was frightened of further injury. She said that she had been very low and depressed, and when Christopher would not let her out of the bedroom, she had thought about jumping out of the window because she did not want to be here anymore. Laura confirmed that the abuse was happening more often and getting worse, and that Christopher had strangled her. Laura said that she told Christopher three days ago that the relationship was over, and she wanted to resume her relationship with Michael. The DASH was graded as high risk, and a referral was made to FearFree and MARAC.
- The Liaison and Diversion service met with Christopher in custody. They recorded that Christopher had reportedly dragged Laura by the hair and pushed her into the kitchen cupboard, alongside damaging a mobile phone and a laptop. It was recorded that Christopher was drinking two litres of vodka a day as well as lager, increasing the risk of misadventure and declining physical health; it was noted that Christopher was engaged with Together Drug and Alcohol Service. Christopher denied any suicidal thoughts or self-harm behaviours. Liaison and Diversion shared the information with Together Drug and Alcohol Service and Christopher’s GP.
- Following the referral to FearFree an IDVA was allocated and they attempted to telephone Laura on the 21st, 22nd and 27th September 2021, Laura did not answer the phone on each occasion and voicemails were left requesting that she call back.
- A MARAC meeting was held on the 28th September 2021. Information was shared by the agencies who held information about Laura and Christopher. The Police Domestic Abuse Officer confirmed that they had not been able to make further contact with Laura; they had sent her an email but were unsure if a reply had yet been received. The Domestic Abuse Officer reported that Laura had returned to her husband, who had also perpetrated domestic abuse against her previously. An action was agreed for the Domestic Abuse Officer to check if they had received a response from the email sent to Laura. If not and there was still no response, attempts were to be made to contact Laura by phone, and the neighbourhood team to attend Laura’s address to check on her welfare.
- On the 4th October 2021 FearFree closed Laura’s case due to non-engagement, as is usual practice after three failed attempts to make contact.
- On the 18th October 2021, Michael attended the emergency department following an overdose. Michael said he had marital difficulties which he had discussed with his friend. He was seen by the Psychiatry Liaison team who provided Michael with information and contact details for Together Drug and Alcohol service, Relate and the Moorings service. GP follow up was further recommended and it was suggested that once alcohol reduction and stabilisation had been achieved a referral to talking therapies could be considered.
- On the 4th March 2022 police received an anonymous call reporting that their friend Laura was a victim of domestic abuse, and that the offender was called Christopher. Officers spoke to Laura and arranged to speak to her at the Police Station later that day, however she did not turn up. Laura sent an email to Devon and Cornwall Police stating that the information that the report they had received was false. Officers later spoke to Laura in person, and she confirmed she did not wish to report any criminal offences. Laura also told the officers that she was back in a relationship with Christopher. No further police action was taken.
- On the 9th April 2022 Michael called police to report that over the last six weeks Laura had been assaulted by Christopher. This included being punched to the head, strangled, bitten on her hand and her fingers bent back. Michael said that Christopher had been controlling Laura, preventing her from reporting the assaults to the Police due to a cannabis grow in the property, which he threatened to blame on her. Officers attended Laura’s home address and located a quantity of cannabis. Christopher was arrested for assault and cultivation of cannabis.
- An initial statement was obtained from Laura, which was also captured on body worn camera, along with photographs taken of bruising to her body. There were also several text messages on Laura’s mobile phone of threats made by Christopher towards Laura of a violent and controlling nature. A DASH risk assessment was completed, with the risk initially graded as medium. The risk was later reassessed by a Domestic Abuse Officer, re-graded as high and referred to MARAC.
- Christopher was formally interviewed and denied assaulting Laura and said her bruising was either because he was acting in self-defence or that she bruised easily during their love making. He also denied sending Laura threatening text messages. Christopher did admit to having knowledge of the cannabis grow at Laura’s house and to setting it up, but continued to say that the grow was Laura’s and not his.
- On the 10th April 2022 Liaison and Diversion assessed Christopher. Christopher explained that he had a trauma history. Christopher said he wanted to be ‘off the planet’, not in a suicidal way, rather he did not want to think or feel. Liaison and Diversion recorded that Christopher was open to Together Drug and Alcohol Service, but was ambivalent about this, saying he had no phone and no means to buy a phone as all money went on alcohol and tobacco. Christopher’s mother had expressed that she felt he may be experiencing schizophrenia. This was based on her observation that Christopher ‘lashes out but cannot remember the incident afterwards.’ Christopher denied hearing voices or having visual hallucinations and there was no evidence of thought disorder. The Liaison and Diversion social worker made a referral to secondary mental health services to support with depression and low mood, but the referral was declined with the rationale that the ‘client needs to address severe alcohol misuse before mental health input can be considered.’
- The matter of the assault upon Laura was reviewed by an Evidential Review Officer and the decision made to obtain further evidence before considering referral to the Criminal Prosecution Service for charging authorisation. This included obtaining a statement from Laura’s husband Michael and obtaining an evidential download of Laura’s mobile phone. Christopher was released on police bail with conditions not to contact Laura or attend her home address.
- FearFree received the referral from the police on the 11th April 2022 and the IDVA spoke to Laura by telephone on the 13th April 2022. Laura said she had moved back in with her husband, Michael, and they were back in a relationship. Laura said Christopher was not allowed to contact her, however Laura was given details about non-molestation orders if things escalated, and if bail conditions were removed. The IDVA agreed to provide Laura with an update after the MARAC meeting.
- On the 19th April 2022 Christopher told his GP that he had suicidal thoughts but no intent or plans. The GP noted that Liaison and Diversion had referred to mental health and advised Christopher that any support from metal health would likely be dependent on him stopping drinking. Christopher said he would not be able to stop drinking. Christopher described lashing out at people and being aggressive when he was frightened and that he often could not remember what had happened. The GP signposted Christopher to the Together Drug and Alcohol Service and the mental health crisis team.
- On the 20th April 2022 police made the referral to MARAC. There was a comment on the MARAC referral that Laura had told the Domestic Abuse Officer that Christopher had been contacting her in breach of his bail conditions. This does not appear to have been followed up or progressed, as a result of individual practice rather than a failing in policy or guidance. Laura told the Domestic Abuse Officer that Christopher had gone back to live with his parents, that she had resumed her relationship with Michael, and they were living together at her home.
- The MARAC meeting took place 25th April 2022. No formal actions were agreed although the Domestic Abuse Officer and IDVA were to continue contact with Laura.
- The IDVA called Laura on the 27th April 2022. There was no answer, and no voicemail was left due uncertainty about the safety to do so.
- In the early hours of the 29th April 2022, Christopher’s mother called an ambulance for Christopher as he was expressing suicidal intent. The mental health desk (Southwest Ambulance Service, Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust) spoke to Christopher, he said he had thoughts to end his life via overdose and had four years’ worth of tablets to take. He said he had been declined mental health support numerous times over the years due to his alcohol use. Christopher confirmed he had not harmed himself and was staying with his mother overnight. The ambulance was stood down due to ‘no current medical need’. Christopher was signposted to mental health helplines for support and a request was made for an urgent GP appointment.
- The GP called Together Drug and Alcohol service, who said that Christopher was closed to the service. The GP referred to the Crisis Resolution Home Treatment team who agreed to contact Christopher later that day. The GP then spoke to Christopher’s mother who reported she had tried various services all week but found no help. She further reported that Christopher was only sober when he woke up, then drank almost continuously when awake. Christopher said he thought about taking an overdose every day and would probably do so later that day. Christopher said he wanted to have medical detox for alcohol, as he could not do the gradual reduction Together wanted him to do. The GP advised contacting Together again to see if they can help with further options for alcohol dependence recovery. The GP recommended a GP review in one week and changed Christopher ‘s prescription to weekly.
- Later that day the Access and First Response Service (AFRS, DPT) contacted Christopher following the referral from his GP. During the triage, Christopher disclosed domestic abuse but made a counter claim that Laura had assaulted him. The triage identified concerns about Christopher’s health due to reports of excessive drinking, Christopher was therefore advised to attend the Emergency Department for a review of his physical health.
- At the follow up GP consultation on the 3rd May 2022 Christopher refused to speak with the GP. Christopher’s mother reported that he was drinking fifteen cans of lager a day and when intoxicated did not want to engage with any support. The GP encouraged support but advised that they were unable to help if Christopher was not willing to engage and to seek urgent medical help should the situation worsen.
- On the 3rd May 2022 the IDVA telephoned Laura and provided an update from the MARAC meeting. Laura said her husband did get angry at times when he is on his own but not in front of her; he had hit her twice in the fifteen years they had been together. The IDVA provided safety advice and gave information so Laura knew she could leave if she wanted to. The IDVA offered support, but Laura said she was ok, and they agreed for the case to be closed. The IDVA text the help desk number to Laura and undertook a DASH which had a score of nine. No individual support plan was developed as the IDVA and Laura did not agree any actions. The case was closed.
- On the 5th May 2022 Christopher’s bail was cancelled, and he was released under investigation. The police log showed that police attended Laura’s address on the same day and left a calling card requesting contact be made. Christopher received a formal caution for production of a Class B drug (cannabis).
- A few days later, Michael’s mother received a text message from Laura at 1647hrs which said: “Thank [Christopher] for leaving his propranolol. I’ve overdosed cos I deal with it.” It is not known when Michael’s mother received or read that text message.
- At 19:42 Michael called 999 after finding Laura unresponsive in bed. The ambulance crew took four minutes to arrive, and Michael was on the phone to 999 control when they entered the property. When asked what had happened, he said ‘I can’t’ and left the room. He confirmed Laura did not have any medical issues, took no regular medication, that she drank often but did not use drugs. On examination Laura was grey, cyanosed, there was no effort of breathing, with no chest rise and fall. Ambulance crew confirmed cardiac arrest and requested back up. Advance Life Support (ALS) was performed, however, after a discussion around Laura’s potential down time, as given by Michael, and after all reversible causes had been considered ambulance crew were advised to cease ALS. Confirmation of death was provided at 20:29 hours. Ambulance crew broke the news to Michael and left the scene immediately due to Michael shouting and becoming increasingly agitated. The crew requested back up from Police who arrived on scene quickly. Police Officers located approximately 150 empty Propranolol blister packets in the bin outside the back door.
Key Issues Arising from the Review
Response to Domestic Abuse and Risk Assessment
- In May 2021 police received the first report of domestic abuse which had occurred between Laura and Michael. Good practice was shown in that police recognised that the situation presented as high risk due to the ending of the relationship. Police formally assessed the risk to Laura using the DASH, identifying a medium risk, which led to a referral to FearFree for IDVA support.
- At the time, the Domestic Abuse Unit (DAU), Devon and Cornwall Police were reviewing all medium risk assessments and did so in this instance. Given that the police had no recorded domestic abuse history, and neither had been referred to MARAC in the past, the outcome of the assessment remained medium risk. Good practice was also demonstrated in identifying a referral to the Fire Service for a fire safety visit because of the threats Michael had made. However, this referral was not actioned and a discussion has since taken place with the staff involved, reflecting on this missed opportunity, and has been passed to the second line supervisor to ensure that the wider team and process learning is embedded, and staff supported. Although the risk of Michael deliberately setting fire to Laura’s property was considered minimal, the visit would have provided Laura with some reassurance.
- The decision by police to take no further action and not to explore a Domestic Violence Protection Notice (DVPN) was based on factors including: no previous domestic abuse reports in relation to Michael or Laura, Michael was very amenable and happy to move away from Laura, Michael had been the one to contact the police requesting intervention and Laura did not support any further police action. Consideration was given to an Evidence Lead Prosecution, however with no evidence provided by either Laura or Christopher the decision was made not to pursue this option.
- Police had noted that Laura, Michael and Christopher were intoxicated and appeared to be ‘heavy drinkers’. With regards to mental health Laura answered “No” to the questions concerning her suffering any mental health conditions or having any suicidal or self-harm ideation and/or attempts. Mental health and alcohol are explored further below.
- Although this was the first report of domestic abuse in respect of Michael, research tells us that on average high-risk victims live with domestic abuse for 2.3 years and medium risk victims for 3 years before getting help. Furthermore, on average victims experience fifty incidents of abuse before getting effective help. It is therefore possible that Laura was experiencing domestic abuse for a period before the first report to police. Professionals should be mindful of this and that help seeking may represent an escalation for the victim.
- The second key episode of involvement with Laura was in September 2021 when she reported an assault by Christopher to police. Good practice was shown through the immediate taking of a statement from Laura and securing evidence through taking photographs of Laura’s injuries and damage to her property. Police officerswill sometimes postpone taking a statement until the following morning and by taking one at the time of the arrest allowed Laura’s evidence to be captured early and minimised the risk of Laura declining to make a statement once the perceived risk had subsided. Furthermore, attending officers captured the arrest and conversations with Laura on body worn video.
- A DASH risk assessment was undertaken and correctly graded as high given the information that Laura shared, which led to a referral for an IDVA and to MARAC. The DASH highlighted the first disclosures around Laura’s mental health. She described feeling low and depressed and made the statement that she did not want to be here anymore and considered taking action in this respect. This statement could be interpreted either as possible suicidal ideation or as the wish to leave the relationship. Either way this was not explored further and may have been useful in assessing risk further, particularly with reference to the domestic abuse suicide timeline which is explored in more detail below.
- No further action was taken in relation to the reported assault as during interview, whilst admitting to causing Laura’s injuries, Christopher said that he did so in self-defence because Laura was attacking him first. Laura had provided a full account of Christopher’s violent behaviour towards her, and this was corroborated by photographic evidence of her injuries. There was body worn video footage, a recording of the 999-call made by Laura, a high-risk DASH and admissions made by Christopher at the time of his arrest and after caution. However, there was an acceptance of Christopher’s version of events that he has acted in self-defence. The fact that an Evidence Lead Prosecution was not considered for all matters and referred to the Crown Prosecution (CPS) for review, is considered a missed opportunity to effectively address Christopher’s criminal offending towards Laura and the associated risk that carried.
- This incident demonstrated a significant escalating risk to Laura. In the DASH undertaken with Laura she said that Christopher was controlling and had tried to strangle her. Furthermore, she said that she wanted to end her relationship with Christopher and re-connect with her husband Michael. She indicated that she had been maintaining contact with Michael and that Christopher was aware of this.
- Non-fatal strangulation is an important predictor of future significant risk. If a woman has been strangled by her partner the risk of attempted murder increases sevenfold and death by a factor of eight. Non-fatal strangulation became an offence under the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 on the 7th June 2022. Where there are no physical signs of strangulation cases can be prosecuted on the account of the victim alone. Unfortunately, the offence was not available when Laura reported that she had been strangled by Christopher but nonetheless the indication for future risk would have been significant.
- Whilst only 50% of victims will have a visible injury as a result of strangulation, victims can experience other physical symptoms both during and after strangulation including: pain, difficulty with breathing and swallowing, problems with sight and hearing, unconsciousness, confusion, agitation, headaches, nausea. Damage to blood vessels in the neck can also lead to stroke days, weeks or even months later. The effects of strangulation will also be psychological. Many victims will think they are going to die and may experience post-traumatic stress disorder leading to flashbacks and nightmares, avoidance, hyperarousal, self-harm and substance misuse.
- The review established that since the introduction of the specific offence of non-fatal strangulation, police have been trained in this respect. Furthermore, the MARAC is coordinated and chaired by Devon and Cornwall police which means that specific knowledge is available to the MARAC and its partner agencies when reviewing cases where non-fatal strangulation has arisen. FearFree are also members of MARAC who can share their knowledge in this area. Health also confirmed that they anticipate training in the area of non-fatal strangulation in the near future.
- It is also well known that separation is a dangerous time with attempts to end a relationship being strongly linked with intimate partner homicide. Forty-one percent of women killed by a male partner/former partner in England, Wales and Northern Ireland in 2018 had separated or taken steps to separate from them. Thirty percent of these women were killed within the first month of separation and sixty-five percent were killed within the first year.
- It was shared via the MARAC process that Christopher had a previous conviction for domestic assault in 2018 and as a result was issued a Restraining Order which expired in September 2020. As part of the MARAC process Laura’s case was held and managed by a police Domestic Abuse Officer (DAO). Prior to the MARAC meeting the DAO put several safety plans in place for Laura including detailed markers linked to both address and individual to alert responding officers to domestic abuse. Both would have provided advance information of risk to officers should they respond to any further calls from Laura and is standard practice for any victim of high domestic abuse.
- There is one recorded action from the MARAC meeting which was for the DAO to contact Laura to find out what her current status was, as there was a suggestion she had resumed a relationship with her husband Michael. However, there was no record of that conversation taking place.
- In March 2022 an anonymous report of domestic abuse towards Laura by Christopher was received by police. Police initiated contact with Laura who assured them that there were no offences to report, and the allegations of domestic abuse were false. Laura also stated she wanted to end her relationship with Christopher and reconnect with her husband Michael.
- Whilst the response in locating and speaking to Laura was good, there did not appear to have been any consideration given to liaising with the local Domestic Abuse Officer, who had been dealing with Laura following the September 2021 incident, or with FearFree and the previously allocated IDVA. This may have provided an opportunity for the DAO or the IDVA to contact Laura to discuss any issues in more detail and to gauge the risk from Christopher. Laura may have felt more comfortable speaking to someone with whom she had already established a relationship with.
- In April 2022 it was Michael who reported domestic abuse, by Christopher towards Laura, to the police. Again, good practice was shown with an initial statement being obtained from Laura by officers at the time Christopher was arrested along with photographs taken of bruising to her body from assaults by Christopher. As referenced above, the early capturing of this evidence is considered good practice as officers sometimes defer the taking of statements until the following day, which can lead to victims not wanting to engage in the investigation process.
- The DASH risk assessment was completed, and the risk was initially graded as medium, despite several of the high-risk questions being answered yes. The risk was later reassessed by the Domestic Abuse Unit and graded as high. This review of the risk also demonstrated good practice as it enabled holistic consideration of Laura and Christopher’s relationship and the escalating behaviour of Christopher towards Laura. Review of medium risk cases was undertaken in recognition that officers attending the scene do not always have all the information available to them, although officers also stated that they are experienced and see the situation in the moment which often presents as more serious. However, in September 2023 the decision was taken for the review of medium DASHs by the DAU to cease due to capacity issues. Whilst the DAU continue to review all high risk DASHs and check for MARAC flags, the cessation of review of medium risk cases is concerning, as in this case the assessment of risk would have remained medium and would not have been referred to MARAC, enabling the sharing of information between agencies and considering the options available to increase Laura’s safety.
- In contrast to the reported offences in September 2021, consideration was given, and the decision made, to obtain further evidence before considering the matter for referral to CPS for charging authorisation. This included obtaining a statement from Michael and obtaining an evidential download of Laura’s mobile phone with the text messages from Christopher, which would have provided evidence to strengthen the case.
- Christopher was released on police bail with the condition not to contact Laura or attend her home address. This was appropriate and proportionate with the matter being referred to MARAC for continued safeguarding and support for Laura. However, because there was a delay in obtaining digital evidence from mobile phones Christopher later had his bail conditions cancelled and he was Released Under Investigation (RUI). This was the wrong decision as it was revealed by Laura that Christopher had been contacting her in breach of his bail conditions.
- Christopher stated that he was living at his mother’s address and was bailed to that address. In May 2021 Christopher was present at Laura’s address and was referred to as a lodger. In September 2022 the assumption was made that the relationship between Laura and Christopher had ended, and Christopher would no longer be residing at her address. In April 2022 he was still living at the address when he was arrested. This gave rise for the review to consider the validity of the address details provided by Christopher. Christopher’s address, had it been provided as Laura’s address, would have influenced decision making. However, the review concluded that it would not be realistic for police to check every address upon release from custody, particularly when there are no conditions in place.
- On the 25th April 2022 the MARAC was provided with the information that Christopher was breaching bail conditions and contacting Laura to withdraw her complaint. This was never explored in more detail to establish what offences Christopher had committed, it was not discussed by the IDVA at the final meeting with Laura and no safety advice given on this specific issue. The breaching of bail conditions by Christopher was a missed opportunity to consider taking a more proactive and robust approach to dealing with him as a person who caused harm in a relationship. It also indicated further risk to Laura, with violations of bail conditions, court orders etc being associated with an increase of risk of future violence and indicated Christopher’s disregard for authority.
- The timeliness of the investigation was standard practice and the delay in obtaining digital evidence from Laura’s mobile phone is well documented and an area of police business that continues to affect many investigations. Digital evidence can only be obtained by specially trained staff and demand for this area of business across all criminal offences is considerable.
- Following the referral from police to FearFree, the FearFree administrator identified the significant risk to Laura and therefore referred for IDVA support before the MARAC form was received. Good practice was demonstrated during the first contact with Laura on the 13th April 2022 when the IDVA discussed the option of a Non-Molestation Order should things escalate, or the bail conditions were removed.
- A safety plan was also initiated during the first meeting with Laura, although the safety plan contained generic safety advice and had not been personalised to Laura’s needs. Furthermore, there was clear evidence of the IDVA attempting to offer on-going support following on from reconciliation with Michael, however, the safety plan was not updated with specific safety advice pertaining to the risk identified as a result of the resuming of that relationship.
- When the MARAC referral was received on the 20th April 2022 and meeting took place on the 25th April, there was knowledge that Christopher had breached his bail conditions. In addition to no action being taken directly in relation to those breaches, there was also a missed opportunity to revisit the option of a Non-Molestation Order.
- Upon closure of the April 2022 referral the IDVA recorded that the DASH was updated. However, there was no documentation to support this, and no recording of the risk outcome. FearFree have identified a need to ensure all case closure procedures are followed. Regardless of whether an individual wishes to engage with the service, it is an expectation that their staff consider all the risks and take any identified safeguarding actions. FearFree were not assured that this was completed in this case and have therefore made a recommendation for their agency in this respect.
- FearFree reported that engaging effectively with Laura did appear challenging, both the IDVA and the DAO struggled to engage with Laura and there was limited evidence of any agency building meaningful relationships with her. Given what is known and understood about trauma, it is questionable whether all agencies, as a whole, did enough to build a relationship with Laura. Furthermore, poor engagement can be a sign of significant risk; Laura may have lacked trust in services and may have felt at risk just talking to them. Whilst agencies were able to visit Laura’s home, this may have been an issue for Laura as it may not have provided a safe space for her. However, there was evidence of safety being discussed, even on occasions when Laura declined support.
- When Christopher’s bail was cancelled on the 5th May 2022, and he was Released Under Investigation, it was recorded that police visited Laura’s home and left a calling card. It is assumed this visit was to inform her of this change but there is no evidence to show that Laura was informed that Christopher was no longer subject to bail with conditions not to contact her. Sharing this information with the IDVA would have enabled them to engage Laura in considering the previously discussed Non-molestation Order. Christopher was still being investigated for this matter a month later when Laura was found deceased.
Mental Health and Suicide
- Domestic abuse has significant psychological consequences for victims, including anxiety, depression, suicidal behaviour, low self-esteem, inability to trust others, flashbacks, sleep disturbances and emotional detachment. Research suggests that forty percent of high-risk victims report having mental health issues, with sixteen percent of victims reporting that they have considered or attempted suicide as a result of the abuse.
- Whilst the DASH includes specific questions around mental health for both the victim and perpetrator, there does not appear to be any recorded or documented link between Laura’s mental health and the ongoing domestic abuse she was experiencing, and missed opportunities to consider the risk she posed to herself. Both MARACs identified Laura’s low mood and suicidal ideation, and whilst it is possible that this was discussed at MARAC meetings, there was no record of this.
- When police attended in April 2022, they completed a Vulnerability Screening Tool and assessed Laura as being at medium risk. This was included in the MARAC referral form which further identified that Laura would like GP support. However, this was not picked up or addressed by the IDVA and there was no evidence of engagement with, or direct referral to, the relevant medical support organisation regarding mental health concerns. There was no discussion about suicidal ideation despite this being clearly identified as an issue within both MARAC referrals. Laura’s mental health was also not acknowledged or referred to within the safety plan in April 2022. FearFree have already undertaken significant actions to improve practice around cases where a risk of suicide is identified. This includes an action plan and fortnightly review meetings to ensure ongoing monitoring and oversight.
- Devon and Cornwall Police reflected that whilst the number of incidents and contacts with Laura during the scoping period was limited, in relation to other ongoing DHRs across Devon and Cornwall, a recurring theme is the increasing number of DHRs where the victim of domestic abuse has taken their own life rather than being killed by a third party.
- Research has shown that amongst people who had attempted suicide, half had experienced intimate partner violence. The Suicide Timeline (Appendix 1) is as a practical tool, for use by professionals, developed through research and analysis of case studies to understand the interactions between perpetrators of coercive control and their victims, and how these interactions may be linked to escalating and de-escalating risk of serious harm or homicide.
- The behavioural data gathered through this research was organised into a sequence of eight stages that represent potential escalating risk. The further along the stages, the higher the risk of serious harm, with opportunities at every stage to cease the progression. Each stage provides indicators of perpetrator and victim characteristics.
- Stage one draws on previous research which identifies that perpetrators are both repeat and serial offenders and that those who employ coercive control are likely to do so in all their intimate relationships. Criminal behaviour does not just relate to a criminal record and previous convictions, but may also be identified through testimony from professionals, the victim, family or the perpetrator themselves. History may also be identified through behavioural characteristics. In relation to the victim, there are identified vulnerabilities from past domestic abuse, sexual abuse, child neglect, bereavement, or eating disorder, and sometimes drug and alcohol misuse which precedes the relationship.
- The early relationship represents stage two and is marked by relationships that develop quickly with early cohabitation, early pregnancy, or early declarations of love. Families report the strong influence exerted by the perpetrator at an early stage and often express concerns about the speed of which the relationship developed.
- Relationships (stage 3) are dominated by intimate partner abuse. Control and violence starts at an early stage within the relationship.
- During stage four the victim identifies the behaviour of the perpetrator as abusive and may start to disclose, usually to friends and family first. Disclosure may be incremental and may come before explicit help-seeking. Disclosure in health settings is common as the environment may feel more confidential and supportive, although research suggests that victims are more likely to disclose to their GPs than in an A&E setting, with victims returning to surgeries 30 or 40 times before managing to disclose domestic abuse.
- Perceived escalation of the seriousness of the abuse is a key factor in the victim deciding to disclose. Equally shame, perpetrator threats, fear over increased violence, and how disclosure will affect social interactions, were reasons for hesitating to reveal abuse.
- In many cases initial disclosure is made to friends or family, escalating to disclosure to police or other services, with early disclosure more common in cases of domestic abuse suicide, than the homicide cases. It is important for practitioners to recognise that a disclosure will not represent the beginning of the risk but will likely be indicating an escalation. Disclosure is distinct from help-seeking as it is more likely to be linked to exploration and validation for the victim.
- Help-seeking can occur in stage five usually after disclosure, and often in response to the victim’s perception that the abuse has escalated, and things have become more serious. Active help-seeking can be seen as a threat to the control exerted by perpetrators, as a result there may be consequences, and the perpetrator may also increase their control in response. Perpetrators are seldom deterred as a result of help-seeking, even if the help sought includes police involvement and results in arrest, prosecutions, civil orders and so on, with perpetrators continuing to exert control despite any sanctions.
- Help-seeking is most commonly sought from mental health services and the police. When help is sought from mental health services the help sought is for mental health linked to the domestic abuse being experienced. However, services do not always make those links explicitly, prescription medication was a more common response than specific help with the abuse.
- The victim’s mental health help-seeking can dominate assessments of them and the victim assessments of themselves leading to self-blame. The victim being perceived as ‘mentally unstable’ creates perceptions that they are culpable in the abuse. This can become worse, and attention further diverted when the victim self-harms, talks about suicide, or makes attempts to kill themselves. In some cases, victims feel that if they receive mental health support they will become ‘strong enough’ to leave the abuser.
- Although suicidal ideation is placed at stage six, this is considered the latest, but most common stage that suicidal ideation was noted in the cases analysed, although in some cases, it appeared in earlier stages, sometimes as early as stage one. Self-harm, suicidal ideation and suicide attempts are sometimes seen as confirmation of mental instability, re-focusing attention on the victim’s mental health rather than the abuse. Suicidal ideation can occur in parallel with homicidal ideation in perpetrators of high-risk abuse, perpetrators can also encourage suicide, and therefore all suicidality should be taken seriously.
- At stage seven the victim feels and sometimes vocalises that they feel trapped in a situation from which there is no escape, and feel that nothing will get better. Where the relationship has ended, contact and control or stalking behaviours can persist.
- Stage eight represents the suicide. The most common method of suicide is ligature and in many cases the perpetrator is the last person to see the victim and discover the victim’s body. It is common for the suicide to be accepted based on the mental health history of the victim, especially if there was a history of suicidal ideation.
- There are characteristics of Laura, Christopher and Michael that are reflected in the Suicide Timeline. Christopher’s history includes a history of domestic abuse. There is little evidence available about the early relationship with Michael, but it is known that Laura’s relationship with Christopher was marked by control, jealousy and violence, with Laura being the subject of that violence which appeared to escalate quickly within the short period of time they were in a relationship. Laura sought help on one occasion when she contacted police in September 2021, but it seems likely that she may have also sought support from Michael in April 2022 resulting in him contacting police. Suicidal ideation was evident in both September 2021 and April 2022 and there was a suggestion of Laura feeling complete entrapment as early as September 2021 when she said to police that ‘she did not want to be here anymore’. That feeling of entrapment may have increased through the contact Christopher made with her in breach of his bail conditions and when the bail was cancelled days before her death.
- The application of the Suicide Timeline begins to shine a light on Laura’s experiences of domestic abuse. Further exploration of the stages with Laura may have helped professionals better understand the risk posed to her and the escalation of risk and consider prevention strategies and interventions.
- FearFree reported that they have introduced a number of measures which are pertinent to Laura’s case, this includes: the provision of Suicide Awareness training as part of the new staff induction programme, with all existing staff enrolled on suicide awareness and prevention training to ensure consistent level of practice; indications of enduring mental health issues or suicidal ideation being recorded as a specific risk in the safety plans, with bespoke actions and guidance relevant to the individual concerned; suicidal ideation identified as a specific “vulnerability” on the database with management quality checks to include ensuring suicidal ideation is recorded correctly, and action plans clearly identify this as a risk, with the appropriate actions in place to support this risk.
Working with people who cause harm in relationships
- The DPT interventions with both Christopher and Michael, in the period subject to review, were relatively brief. In May 2021, following the first report of domestic abuse, Michael was assessed by Liaison and Diversion whilst in police custody. He engaged in the assessment and identified that alcohol was a problem that affected his relationships. However, whilst the assessment undertaken was completed to a good standard it did not identify, and therefore explore, domestic abuse. DPT commented that they are usually only aware of the category of offence when they meet with individuals, for example, common assault, ABH, GBH etc. DPT reflected on the interface between clinical and criminal, that translating a crime to an incident of domestic abuse may lead to a change in approach and the opening up of other support networks.
- Michael’s next contact with mental health services was following detention under s.136 of the Mental Health Act, Michael informed the assessors that he is not able to see his wife due to there being a 28 day injunction against him preventing contact with Laura. Both interactions with mental health services identified that Michael had no ongoing mental health need at that time. Following the Mental Health Act Assessment, the Approved Mental Health Professional (AMHP) did explore, and provide advice about, the link between Michael using alcohol and the impact this would have on his medication which he was taking for depression.
- Christopher was seen by Liaison and Diversion in September 2021. Liaison and Diversion were aware on this occasion of the domestic abuse nature of the offence and identified excessive alcohol intake. They assessed him again in April 2022 when his mental health difficulties became more apparent. Consideration of Christopher’s presentation and his trauma history evidenced exploration of the potential root causes to the presenting challenges and a holistic assessment. This assessment with Christopher resulted in an onward referral to secondary mental health services which was refused due to his alcohol consumption.
- There is evidence of robust risk assessments by the Liaison and Diversion service which is evidence of compliance with DPT policy about routine enquiry in relation to domestic abuse.
- DPT’s final intervention with Christopher during the scoping period was in late April 2022 via the Access and First Response Service who explored domestic abuse with Christopher. However, there is no evidence that this was followed up with services for people who cause harm in relationships. The AFRS triage identified potential significant concerns with Christopher and his physical health due to reports of excessive alcohol consumption and so he was advised to attend the local Emergency Department, which he agreed to do the following day, although there is no evidence that he did so.
- Both Christopher and Michael were, at the time of DPT involvement, potential perpetrators of Domestic Abuse towards Laura. DPT policy and guidance for staff around domestic abuse focuses on how to intervene and respond to concerns from the perspective of victims. Neither Christopher nor Michael was identified as victims of domestic abuse, although Christopher did allege he was assaulted by Laura. This raises the question as to whether there needs to be policy to identify practice standards for working with people who may be a person who is causing harm.
- Research supports there being high levels of mental health problems amongst those who cause harm in relationships. Along with other risk factors, research has found mental health needs are associated with increased risk of domestic homicides. In one study forty percent of people who caused harm had suicidal ideation/attempts or had self-harmed prior to the incident. This was the case for both Michael and Christopher; they both experienced suicidal ideation during the scoping period and self-harmed through the use of alcohol.
- Research has also found mental health professionals reporting ‘low’ or ‘very low’ levels of knowledge regarding domestic abuse, along with a lack of skills and confidence in enquiring about and exploring abuse. Whilst some practitioners find it easier to enquire about perpetration – as this aligns with routine risk assessments – they also report a significant lack of training in how to respond to people who cause harm in relationships. This lack of training and guidance was highlighted by DPT.
- Christopher had regular contact with his GP during April and May 2022. Christopher’s GP practice commented that whilst records clearly recorded depression, anxiety and abuse of alcohol there is no exploration as to what might be behind Christopher’s history. Christopher had referred to having flash backs of past trauma, albeit outside of the scoping period, there was no evidence of staff exploring this past trauma further.
- Whilst agencies responded to the mental health concerns for both Michael and Christopher and the incidents of domestic abuse were responded to by police and domestic abuse services, neither were held accountable for their abusive behaviour.
- Home Office analysis showed that of those being managed, supervised or attending a service, including drug and alcohol services, probation, Multi-Agency Public Protection Arrangements, mental health services, only seven percent of people who caused harm were attending, or had attended, a domestic abuse programme.
- In Devon, FearFree provide the Behaviour Change Support programme to people who cause harm in relationships. The aim of this work is to provide bespoke one to one support and advocacy for adults in order to change their harmful and abusive behaviours and promote the safety of victims and their children.
- FearFree reported that since the beginning of this contractual year (to December 2023) they have actively engaged forty-nine clients on the Behaviour Change programme. Of interest, one third of these clients identified alcohol or drug addiction and one quarter identified significant and enduring mental health issues. Furthermore, since the introduction of the programme the service has gathered information around the percentage of those on the programme who have identified witnessing or experiencing domestic abuse as a child or an adult, that figure is ninety-seven percent. Although it is not known whether Michael or Christopher had previously experienced or witnessed domestic abuse this factor appears to be significant and worthy of further exploration in other domestic abuse cases.
- In terms of uptake in the Behaviour Change programme FearFree identified a significant gap between the number of victims and perpetrators they work with, for example, last year FearFree worked with approximately 250 clients on the Behaviour Change programme and yet they supported around 3000 victims of domestic abuse. One explanation is that the Behaviour Change programme is voluntary and needs some level of recognition and acceptance by the person causing harm of the impact their behaviour has on their families and so one could argue that due to the voluntary nature of the programme FearFree may not be engaging with those individuals who may struggle to take ownership of their behaviour and its impact.
- FearFree report a re-offending rate of 8% (domestic abuse specific crimes) across an 18 month period for those who complete the programme, compared to a re-offending rate for overall crimes of ten percent. However, FearFree are unable to compare with the re-offending rate for domestic abuse specific crimes for those who have not engaged in the programme.
- At time that services were responding to the domestic abuse that Laura was experiencing, the referral route for the Behaviour Change programme was via the police and the programme only took clients who were deemed suitable by the integrated offender management teams. However, since April 2023 the funding has changed and allows for both self-referral and referrals from other agencies. Despite this referral remain low- and FearFree are keen to raise awareness with all agencies who may be working with families and who would benefit from this support. In addition, FearFree have now arranged for Behaviour Change workers to attend every MARAC to promote the programme and raise awareness of the impact that working with people who cause harm could have on the overall safety of the victim.
Alcohol
- Both Michael and Christopher used alcohol, and both appear to have been change resistant drinkers. There was evidence of both being referred to Together Drug and Alcohol service. There appears to have been a belief at times that Christopher was engaged with the service but he had not engaged or been open to the service since March 2021. Together reported that signposting to their service during the scoping period was not evident.
- Where alcohol is involved in domestic abuse, much of the evidence suggests that it is not the root cause, but rather a compounding factor, sometimes to a significant extent. In a randomly selected sample of DHRs the AVA Project found that in sixty-nine percent of DHRs alcohol was mentioned as a negative issue.Whilst there is evidence that alcohol use by people who cause harm in relationships, and to a lesser extent by those who experience harm, increases the frequency of violence and the seriousness of the outcomes, this does not mean that alcohol use causes domestic abuse. It is neither an excuse nor an explanation, whereby people who cause harm are all too often depicted in terms of the ‘stereotype’ of a drunk who loses control and assaults their partner.
- The DASH includes the question ‘Has (the perpetrator) had problems in the past year with drugs (prescription or other), alcohol or mental health leading to problems in leading a normal life?’ Therefore, the assessment recognises the use of alcohol as a high-risk factor, however, consultation through the AVA project found that participants commonly felt that this question did not do justice to the potential significance of alcohol problems in domestic abuse.
- The AVA project has produced guidance on how to address domestic abuse and alcohol use. The aim of the guidance is to create a baseline of good practice for those supporting clients that have been understood to be change resistant drinkers and who are perpetrating or experiencing domestic violence. This guidance may be useful to agencies who are working with people who experience, and people who cause, harm where alcohol is a factor.
- The use of alcohol and other drugs is widely understood to be a means of coping with traumatic life experiences and a significant proportion of problem drinkers also have a mental health problem. This combination is associated with high levels of suicide, self-harm and violence to others and makes clients difficult to engage in services or treat effectively. This was indeed the case for both Michael and Christopher. Both experienced mental health issues and there was evidence of both having experienced past trauma.
- Despite the established link between alcohol and mental health, a referral for Christopher to secondary mental health services was declined on the basis that he needed to address his alcohol misuse before mental health intervention could be considered. This response can be frustrating and appear counterintuitive to the client, their families and other professionals. DPT were able to share with the review panel the complex dynamic between alcohol and mental health, explaining that in order to achieve therapeutic change an individual requires the ability to think in depth and reflect which is limited by alcohol and therefore alcohol needs to be controlled to a certain level for any therapeutic intervention to be effective.
- Together countered this by highlighting that their service works with anyone experiencing a substance misuse issue including those experiencing mental ill health. The work they do with their clients also involves talking about the past and that it is their experience that despite the use of alcohol clients are able to take on information, think deeply and reflect. Together emphasized that it is not necessarily the level of alcohol use that is the prominent factor but the capacity of the individual to engage linked to their alcohol tolerance.
- The perspectives and approaches taken by agencies in relation to alcohol and mental ill health only reinforces the complexities in working with this client group.
- Laura also used alcohol, although the extent to which she did so is unknown. She had not sought support from Together and it was not highlighted as an issue by any of the agencies, except for the police who noted she was intoxicated when they attended her address in response to the reported incidents.
- Victims may be using alcohol as a means of coping with the abuse. Victims are also more likely to use violence to defend themselves, or in retaliation, when they have been drinking. This can make it hard for agencies to discern who is the cause of harm and who is the person experiencing harm. Fortunately, in this case police were able to identify that Laura was the one experiencing harm and Michael and Christopher the cause of harm.
- A particular concern to be addressed is the frequency with which victims of domestic abuse who use alcohol problematically are viewed negatively because of their alcohol use. For example, victims may be seen as causing the abuse that is perpetrated against them due to their own seemingly antisocial behaviour, including their use of violence to defend themselves. It is possible that the professionals in this case held this bias unconsciously when responding to and supporting Laura.
Domestic Abuse Support and Advice for Professionals
- Training in domestic abuse is available for all staff and officers within Devon and Cornwall Police and continues to be constant, relevant, and current. Force Policy and Guidance in relation to domestic abuse is reviewed and updated yearly by the Strategic Safeguarding Improvement Hub. In the last twelve months Devon and Cornwall Police has reviewed its operating model for responding to and investigating domestic abuse and made considerable changes. These include the formation of a specialist team of investigators for all matters of domestic abuse. These teams are referred to as Moonstone and are embedded in each Local Policing Area and offer a consistent approach across the force to domestic abuse. Officers on Moonstone also received further specialist training in domestic abuse matters.
- Medical Centre A reported that the practice has historically received Identification and Referral to Improve Safety (IRIS) training and can access a designated practitioner that’s linked across the Primary Care Network (PCN). The practice also has a domestic abuse policy in place that provides guidance on how to identify and respond to domestic abuse. This includes guidance on people who cause harm in relationships.
- The Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust report that if a professional has concerns about a patient being a victim of domestic abuse, they can immediately open up conversations, gain consent for referrals to the Health IDVA, RDUH safeguarding team or MARAC. The Trust also has a domestic abuse leaflet which can be shared with patients. The leaflet has an explanation of what domestic abuse is and contains information about accessing support and safety planning. The Trust has a domestic abuse policy and further guidance, information on referrals and contacts that are accessible to staff via the Trust intranet. The RDUH employs a Health IDVA specifically to support staff and patients who are experiencing domestic abuse.
- In addition, all clinical staff at RDUH complete a mandatory domestic abuse module. The training changed from a one-off training to three yearly repeat training in 2022 and staff across the Trust are in the process of renewing their compliance. In July 2023 79.6% of staff were compliant in their domestic abuse training. Bespoke domestic abuse training sessions are also available for teams when the need for training and support is identified or requested.
- Together Drug and Alcohol Service offers three specific Domestic abuse training courses: Domestic Abuse Level 2, Domestic Abuse Perpetrators and Domestic Abuse Victims. During the time period in scope for this DHR, Together staff received training on Domestic Abuse through the generic Safeguarding Training (Level 2). Staff may have had more dedicated development on this topic through on-the-job training and shadowing but attended no formal session through Together. Staff may also access Domestic Abuse training through local/partner organisations at one off events such as a recent event from FearFree. Together are a main agency within the MARAC process and have representation on the MARAC steering group.
- FearFree is the specialist domestic abuse service in Devon. All employees of the service receive a full formal induction and training in all areas of domestic abuse. IDVAs are encouraged to undertake the IDVA qualification, following their probation period, if they do not already possess it. Advice and support are available to employees from line managers in addition to formal four weekly one to ones and six weekly supervision.
Communication and Information Sharing
- Three of the four key episodes of involvement with Laura assessed the risk as reaching the threshold for inter-agency information sharing resulting in referrals to FearFree for IDVA support and two referrals to MARAC. Agencies that were not actively involved at the time were made aware of the domestic abuse risk as a result of the MARACs. For example, The Trust was not aware of any risk to Laura until September 2021 when her case was heard at MARAC. There is good evidence of information sharing, as one of the core agencies for MARAC the Trust is informed of everyone who is discussed at each MARAC meeting. The Trust flags the records of all victims in order to raise staff awareness to enable support to be provided. Following Laura’s referral to MARAC in September of 2021 the flag was placed on her electronic record system alerting staff to the risks. Had she attended the Trust again this flag would have advised staff to be more vigilant to the risk and open up conversation where possible with the victim. There is also evidence within the notes of multi-agency working and information sharing between RDUH and the mental Health Trust Devon Partnership Trust (DPT) and the RDUH and multi-agency partners via MARAC.
- There was also strong evidence of a good working relationship and information sharing between FearFree and the Police’s Domestic Abuse Officer.
- As already stated, there were some missed opportunities to share information. This included following the anonymous contact in March 2022 whereby sharing information with the DAO and FearFree might have enabled further support to Laura, assessment of risk and safety planning.
- The quality of the information shared in the NICHE automated referrals from police to FearFree, following NICHE implementation which included changes to information sharing of medium risk DASHs, was highlighted as a potential issue by the review. Devon and Cornwall police acknowledged that sharing had, at times, been greater in the past but that previously some of that information was not properly reviewed and assessed for sharing. The new NICHE system provides information without danger of inappropriate sharing and does not require intensive management input, which took staff away from core responsibilities. It was accepted that the automated system relies on the quality of Public Protection Notice (DASH) completion by attending officers and it was recognised that this human input can be a failure point, although there is monitoring of the quality of entries in the Central Safeguarding Teams, with training and advice provided to those officers identified as failing in the area. Devon and Cornwall police further confirmed that there is a monthly working group in place to monitor the Public Protection Notice progress and identify learning and improvements.
- Devon and Cornwall police said that if FearFree identify cases of low-quality referrals, they are encouraged to contact the police domestic abuse teams so that further appropriate information sharing can be considered, the Public Protection Notice can be quality assured, and the inputting officer engaged with. Devon and Cornwall police gave assurances that any learning would be because of individual deviation from best practice and not as a result of a systems, process, or policy failing. Furthermore, FearFree confirmed that they are working with the Devon and Cornwall police Learning and Development department to raise awareness of domestic abuse and how to complete referrals.
- As part of discussions about working with people who cause harm the review explored the risks and benefits of ‘flagging and tagging’ on agency systems to assist in identification of domestic abuse perpetrators and sharing information. Devon and Cornwall police confirmed that if a person who is causing harm is part of a MARAC discussion, they will also have a MARAC ‘marker’ on them. They also identified that often, ‘markers’ are put onto a system at the initial stages of an investigation, when the individual might not have been charged with an offence, and therefore there is a requirement to be compliant with GDPR. However, by having a marker, it enables actions such as DVDS to be undertaken, and allows the opportunity for information sharing. The panel identified that a marker could prompt professionals to enquire and ask more questions, but that consideration should be given to their relevancy and accessibility on agency systems. Furthermore, the identification of a person as ‘a perpetrator’ needs to be done in an ethical way, that does not then risk labelling someone and attributing that label incorrectly. The panel concluded that any move to add such markers was likely not practicable and assured the review that MARAC markers are used across agencies.
Conclusions and Lessons to be Learned
- In the final year of her life, Laura experienced domestic abuse from both Michael and Christopher. Unfortunately, little is known about Laura, and her lived experience, other than that reported by the agencies that contributed to this review. However, the risk to Laura was escalating during this period, which may have led to her feeling trapped in the situation. In consideration of this escalation and feelings of entrapment, alongside other predisposing factors and identified risks, this increased the risk of suicide, as demonstrated through the application of the Suicide Timeline.
- The review has highlighted the importance of the use of domestic abuse risk assessments and how this enabled a multi-agency response through the MARAC and the availability of support from both the IDVA and Domestic Abuse Officer. However, there are concerns that the review of risk assessment by police, which has ceased due to resource and capacity constraints, which in this case, would now result in the assessment of risk relating to the April 2022 incident remaining medium with no referral to MARAC. This therefore has implications for current and future cases of domestic abuse identified by Devon and Cornwall police.
- Whilst good practice was shown by police in the immediate taking of statements, use of body worn cameras, securing evidence and consideration of an evidence led prosecution following the report in April 2022, there were also missed opportunities in the earlier reports of domestic abuse whereby Christopher’s account of self-defence was too readily accepted. The MARAC also lacked evidence of holding people who cause harm to account and this is reflected in the low numbers of people who cause harm accessing the Behaviour Change Programme compared to the number of those experiencing domestic abuse that are supported by FearFree.
- Overall, the review concluded that in this case the people causing harm were not held to account, and this may be attributable to a lack of knowledge and guidance across all agencies about how to work with people who cause harm in relationships, exacerbated by challenges around identification.
- The review also recognised the challenges and complexities of working with people who experience ill mental health and use alcohol and how this can limit access to services and the successfulness of interventions.
- The review has also highlighted the changes that have been made as both a result of the early learning from this review and changes that have occurred since Laura’s death which indicate an opportunity to make the future safer and reduce the risk of reoccurrence of such a tragedy.
Recommendations
- Agencies to develop a specific policy, review and/or raise awareness of existing policies around how staff should work with people who cause harm in relationships.
- FearFree to raise awareness of the Behaviour Change programme.
- To share learning in reference to the Suicide Timeline with the Suicide Prevention Group and request consideration of its inclusion in the suicide prevention plan and domestic abuse suicide workstream.
- Devon and Cornwall Police to consider the current process to review, action and share information from domestic abuse risk assessments to ensure consistency across the Force and maximise safeguarding opportunities with other agencies.
- To increase awareness of the learning from this review through production of a learning briefing and to seek assurances that lessons from this review have been disseminated to staff within agencies and incorporated into current domestic abuse training.
- With specific reference to paragraph 16.40, Devon and Cornwall police to ensure that the nature of an offence is shared with Liaison and Diversion, for example domestic abuse, and that Liaison and Diversion request details of the nature of an offence, when a person is detained in custody.
Appendix 1 – The Suicide Timeline | Stage | Reported perpetrator characteristics | Victim characteristics |
| History | History of domestic abuse, coercive control, stalking, routine jealousy, violence, history of criminal behaviour | History of vulnerability. Previous domestic abuse, coercive control or sexual assault, away from home (student), previous local authority care |
| Early Relationship | Speed and intensity | Speed and intensity |
| Relationships | Dominated by controlling patterns, violence in many cases | Subject to violence, drugs and alcohol, sexual violence |
| Disclosure | Control escalating, violence may escalate, persistent harassment | Starts to tell other about the abuse |
| Help-Seeking | Reported perpetrator may use victims mental health against them, may make threats to family/friends, counter allegations | Mental health services, GP for mental health, A&E, child services, social services, police |
| Suicidal Ideation | Reported perpetrator may encourage suicide, persistent contact, threats | Suicide attempts, self-harm, may so they ‘can’t go on’, may be convinced they will be killed, may have lost custody of the children |
| Complete Entrapment | Stalking, threats, persistent contact, threats to others, violence | May say ‘I will never be free’ or similar, |
| Suicide | Common for reported perpetrators to find body, in some cases abuse transferred to victim’s family | Most common to be at home with ligature, other methods also noted |